Iowa Co-Op Landus Sues former CEO Matt Carstens And Other Executives

Landus alleges its former CEO, general counsel and board chair concealed a salary that grew to about $4.4 million, homes and a $904,000 foundation payment for a project never built.

Landus news collage 2
Landus has announced its new health insurance program, the acquisition of independent chemical distributor Wickman Chemical, and the launch of Landus Advantage.
(Images via Landus Cooperative)

Landus Cooperative has sued its former CEO, former general counsel and former board chair in Polk County, Iowa, alleging breach of fiduciary duty, fraud and unjust enrichment tied to Matt Carstens’ 2020-2025 tenure.

The petition, which Landus released Nov. 17, names Matt Carstens, his wife Shanda Carstens, the Matt & Shanda Carstens Family Foundation, former general counsel Stephen Nielsen and former board chair Matthew Chambers. The allegations have not been tested in court, and no defendant response was available at the time of writing.

What the petition alleges

According to the petition, Carstens’ base salary grew from $625,000 to about $4.4 million through employment agreement amendments that Nielsen drafted, several of which the full board allegedly never saw.

Landus also alleges:

  • Homes: The cooperative committed to pay for a Florida home ($10 million) and an Iowa home ($3.5 million), plus tax gross-ups, and paid the Iowa amount as a lump sum in 2023.
  • Foundation payment: About $904,000 went to the Carstens Family Foundation between December 2023 and February 2024 for a “Performance Center” that was never built. Landus says invoices for the CEO’s personal residence were combined with that project’s invoices. Polk County denied a zoning variance for the project in January 2024.
  • Personal use of resources: Landus employees allegedly worked as household staff for the family. For example, “Personal Wellness Assistants” who “cooked for the Carstens, cleaned the Carstens’s home, did yard work at the Carstens’s home and, according to detailed daily checklists, laid out Mr. Carstens’s robe and slippers and tucked his heated blanket into the side of his bed.”
  • Misuse of corporate assets and staff. It’s also alleged the family used the corporate plane was for personal trips. One example, Carstens’ daugther’s 21st birthday in 2024. The Landus jet flew the family from Iowa to Florida. Carstens told “three of the Landus-paid personal assistants to go to Florida two days before the Carstens family arrived on the Landus jet, so they could buy food and alcohol (to be paid for by Landus) and get the Florida house ready. One personal assistant was required to chauffeur the Carstens children and their friends from bar to bar until 2:00 a.m. on the daughter’s 21st birthday, for which the personal assistant was paid overtime by Landus.”
  • Other payment: A $280,000 payment went to an LLC tied to a contractor, with whom Carstens was allegedly having an affair, and Landus says it cannot confirm meaningful services were provided.
  • Conflict of interest: Nielsen allegedly represented Carstens and the Foundation while serving as Landus’ lawyer, without disclosing it to the board. Nielsen was Landus Executive Vice President and General Counsel from April 2020 until April 2025.
  • Board information: Chambers allegedly withheld information from the board and described compensation as an “Executive Committee matter.” Chambers is from Audubon, Iowa and served as
    Chair of the Landus Board of Directors from February 2023 until June 2025.
  • Severance: Carstens received $1.5 million (June 2025) and Nielsen $550,000 (May 2025). Landus alleges it signed those agreements without knowing of the concealed conduct.

The petition brings six counts: breach of fiduciary duty (Carstens; Nielsen and Chambers), fraud and fraudulent concealment, aiding and abetting, and unjust enrichment. Landus seeks damages, disgorgement of compensation and benefits, restitution, and punitive damages on the fraud counts.

Landus’ response

Landus says operations continue “without interruption” and its farmer-owners and customers should expect business as usual while the court sorts out the claims.

In a statement, Landus said its board “takes its responsibility to protect the business, its assets and member trust very seriously” and that the decision to sue followed a stepwise investigation over the last year. It framed the case as living out its “Integrity in Action” core value.

The cooperative also pointed to governance changes the board has made over the past year, including greater transparency, stronger financial oversight and clearer accountability, and published a separate governance improvements document. Farmer members and customers with questions can call Landus at (855) 662-7233.

Background

Landus announced April 4, 2025, that Carstens was stepping down as president and CEO, a move the board and Carstens described as mutual. Chambers became acting CEO and Nielsen also left that month. Before the announcement, social media accounts had posted accusations against Carstens, which he called “baseless and unequivocally false” in March 2025, and Landus had announced a 10% workforce reduction in January 2025.

Sam Caton served as interim CEO, and Landus named Eric Heismeyer, formerly of Bunge and ADM, as its next CEO. Landus is Iowa’s largest farmer-owned cooperative, with more than 5,500 farmer-owners and about $2.4 billion in business.

The Scoop first reported Carstens’ departure in April 2025.

Scoop-logo (1346x354)
Read Next
ARA’s Hunter Carpenter says a Dec. 11 funding deadline, a likely farm bill extension and a long-shot H-2A bill define the lame duck, while ARA’s 2027 priorities hold steady under a Democratic Congress.
Follow the Scoop
Get Daily News
Get Markets Alerts
Get News & Markets App